==========
Welcome to yet another "Ask Adam..." blog post. Where readers of the blog send me their life, love, sex, relationship and other pressing questions. I'll do my best to answer and advise them here on the blog and other readers will be able to weigh in too.
Enjoy.
If you ever want to email me a question, problem or issue to possibly be shared here or just wanna say "Hi." click here to send me an email. And of course whatever you send is anonymous, you don't even have to give your name.
==========
Today's letter is about a situation I'm sure we've all been through in some way or another...
Hey Adam,
I'm new to your blog and I must say that I really love it. I know that you sometimes give advice on issues, so I wanted to get your advice on something. I'm a 25 year old male and I've been dating dudes for a while. Recently my best friend said that he was talking to someone online that sounds a lot like a dude I used to date. Come to find out it was and he asked me if it was okay to talk to him. I told him do what his heart tells him to do, but deep down I really don't like the idea. Me and the dude were not serious or anything. My question to you is, when is it ok for friends to date the same dude or is it ever? I know its kind of difficult in this lifestyle not to run into this but it still gets under my skin.
-Over It
Dear Over It,
In the words of Kim Catrall a.k.a. Samantha Jones from "Sex And The City", I must say to you, "Oh honey..." I wish I could feel sorry for you, but unfortunately you've done this to yourself, you've fucked on your bed and now you have to lie in the wet spot. Before we get into your specific situation, I'll answer your general question first.
Yes, the gay scene and more specifically, the ethnic gay scene is a microcosm of a microcosm, so even here in New York, the largest city in this great nation of the United States you're bound to run into some of the same players in different capacities from time to time. The situation of 'my best friend wants to date my ex' is all too common and now that I think about it I'm kinda surprised that it's taken this long for this particular issue to have come up here. I can't give a solid general answer as to whether this whole thing is universally okay or not. I believe that it should be dealt with on a case-by-case, person-by-person basis, contingent upon the parties involved.
In my experience I've tended to look at things this way. If I'm broken up with someone, like really broken up, all emotional and sexual ties have been severed, a considerable amount of time has elapsed, all wounds have healed, and better yet, we've even become amicable or friendly, and that person that I have broken up with can find happiness with my friend and or my friend can find happiness with them, however or whoever initially put things into motion, and they went about connecting with each other in the most honest and forthright way with respect to my feelings, I say why not, who am I to block someone else's blessing? Just because we didn't work doesn't mean it can't work with a friend or an associate. The being forthright thing though is extremely important as not being forthright about things could imply that the ex and the friend were messing around all along. That's also where good judgment is important. Obviously best friend and ex aren't, or rather shouldn't get together two weeks after y'all break up, this situation, even if born of genuine innocence (which I'd highly doubt) would still leave room for speculation of preexisting wrongdoing.
I remember a time once when there was a guy who really liked me and he was really going hard trying to get my attention. I told him that nothing could ever happen between us because he dated my best friend. I figured that he probably wasn't serious about me anyway, just only physically attracted to me and was using my best friend's absence as an opportunity to mess around. After having squelched his advances toward me retorting that same thing over and over again he took it upon himself one day to call my best friend on speakerphone in my presence to tell him how he felt about me and ask whether it was all okay. Although at that moment I really wasn't so much into him and previously didn't trust his motives, having seen him take that action, being so forthright and respectful of my best friend's feelings made me see him in a different light. My best friend was actually fine with it and I decided, 'hey why not?' and gave the guy a shot. It was a total fucking disaster, biggest mistake ever, but for unrelated reasons.
For this sort of thing to work smoothly three things are absolutely imperative:
1. You and your ex must have had to had broken up on good terms and if not on good terms at least by now have worked past all that and are amicable or friendly even with no lingering romantic feelings from either party.
2. The ex and the friend must approach the idea of forming their union in the most forthright and honest way with regard to your feelings on the matter. Meaning, they have to tell you what's going on before they engage in anything serious like dating, sex, etc.
3. Most importantly, you must agree to it all.
See, this what you did. Okay, so alright, out of your own mouth you said that the ex wasn't exactly the love of your life, it wasn't that serious, okay. So your friend 'innocently' stumbled across a guy online that turned out to be your ex and he asked you whether it was okay to date him. Your friend in his own way followed steps one and two, you fucked up step three. When he asked you whether it was okay you had the power to stop this from happening, but instead of saying how you really felt, you gave the passive-aggressive, answer of "do what your heart tells you to do", say what? What kinda shit is that? You asked for this. I mean, follow what his heart tells him to do, his heart was gon' tell him to go after the guy, like duh, but you expected for his heart to sense your reluctance and give him pause after you already gave him the green light. Instead of being the quote-unquote 'bad guy' and/or admitting or making it seem like you still had feelings for your ex by stopping this from happening, you expected your best friend to stop things himself.
I realize that your feelings of discomfort with this may not even be from having lingering romantic feelings for your ex. I mean an ex is an ex for a reason, maybe you just don't want him around you anymore, hence the break up, and you know that if he gets with your best friend, naturally you're gonna have to be around him again, maybe you just don't like the potential weirdness of it all. Whatever the reason, it was up to you to decide, your best friend didn't sneak around your back. He came to you, giving you the full opportunity to stop things if you chose to do so, you chose not to do so. Kids, one of these days we're gonna realize that most people aren't mind readers and that if we want something from someone we must verbalize it, specifying to that person exactly what it is we want and if we don't do that and subsequently don't get what we want we cannot under any circumstances be mad about it.
So what do we do now? There isn't much to do except to talk to your friend. I'm presuming that this involvement between him and your ex is fairly new and they probably haven't made wedding plans as of yet. Tell him exactly how you feel, don't lie or sugarcoat, if you still want the ex, don't wanna be around the ex, whatever it is let your friend know the absolute truth. Now the ball is in his court. More than likely, if he's your best friend like you say he is, then he probably wouldn't wanna let a new relationship cause potential strife between you and him, and would probably break things off. Although if he decided to stick with his new relationship with your ex he's well within his rights to do so and if you are his best friend like you say you are then you'd have to suck it up and deal with it, with no whining, bitching, or complaining. See what happens when you give your power to someone else?
-Adam
If you ever want to email me a question, problem or issue to possibly be shared here or just wanna say "Hi." click here to send me an email. And of course whatever you send is anonymous, you don't even have to give your name.
==========
Playing In The Background...
"Not Anymore"
by LeToya
from the album "Lady Love"
==========